Most rejections are technical: background noise above −60 dB, levels outside −23 to −18 dB RMS, peaks above −3 dB, or files that don’t sound alike. The rest come from listening: audible edits, mouth noise, missing credits. Each has a number or a rule you can check before you upload again.
ACX checks every file against a short list of technical rules, then a person listens to part of the book. A notice usually names the rule. Find yours below.
Noise floor above −60 dB
The most common one. The noise floor is the quietest your recording ever gets: the hum and hiss between sentences. ACX wants it below −60 dB. A fridge, a laptop fan or a charger near the mic will usually put you at −50.
Fix: switch off what hums, then re‑record, or clean the noise without touching the voice. Heavy noise reduction leaves a watery, metallic sound that fails the listening check instead. Full steps: noise floor too high.
Too quiet or too loud
ACX wants the average level, measured as RMS, between −23 and −18 dB. Home recordings land around −27 because people sit back from the mic. Turning the file up fixes the level but lifts the noise with it, which is how a level fix turns into a noise‑floor rejection.
Fix: sit a hand’s width from the mic and record at a level that peaks well below the top of the meter. Then raise the level and control the noise together. Full steps: RMS too low, RMS too high.
Peaks above −3 dB
A peak is the loudest instant in a file: a laugh, a “p” that pops, a raised voice. ACX allows −3 dB at most. A limiter catches these. If the waveform is flat‑topped, the mic clipped while recording, and that can’t be undone.
Fix: run a limiter set to −3 dB. Clipping can’t be fixed afterwards: move back a hand’s width or turn the input down, then record that part again. Full steps: peaks too high.
Files that don’t match
ACX listens across the book. If chapter 3 was recorded in another room, or one file is noticeably louder, it gets flagged even when every file passes on its own. Keep each file within about 1.5 dB of the others and record in the same place, with the same mic, at the same distance. Full steps: chapters that don’t match.
Room tone at the start and end
Every file needs a short stretch of quiet room sound: 1 to 5 seconds before you speak and after you finish, and never more than 5. Digital silence doesn’t count, and neither does a fade. Trimming too close to the first word is a common cause. Full steps: room tone.
Format and length
- MP3 at 192 kbps or higher, constant bit rate, 44.1 kHz.
- Every file mono, or every file stereo. Mono is the safe choice.
- One chapter or section per file, 120 minutes at most.
Exports from voice memo apps and some editors default to variable bit rate. Re‑export at 192 kbps CBR. Full steps: MP3 format, mono or stereo, file too long.
Credits and the retail sample
ACX expects opening and closing credits as their own files, and a retail sample of one to five minutes. The sample shouldn’t start with credits. A chapter should start by saying its own title.
What ACX hears
The listening check catches what numbers can’t: an edit that cuts a breath in half, a line read twice, mouth clicks, a dog, a phone ping under the voice. Listen to every chapter once, all the way through, before uploading.
Fix them in this order
- Run every file through a check to see which rules fail and by how much.
- Fix the noise first. Every other fix depends on it.
- Set the level, then limit the peaks.
- Trim room tone and export at 192 kbps CBR.
- Listen once, all the way through.
The free ACX Check does step one in your browser for a whole book at once. If a recording can’t be saved, it says so, with what to change before you record again.