Skip to content

Guide · 5 min read

It passed the check. ACX rejected it anyway.

A checker reads numbers. ACX says its own one, Audio Lab, does not detect noise floor or editing errors: its quality assurance team reviews for those after you submit. In authors’ own reports, passing files come back for heavy noise reduction, pauses processed to silence, or a reading too close to the limit.

What each check reads

CheckReadsWorth knowing
ACX Audio LabRMS, peak levels, bit rate, bit rate method, sample rate, mixed channels, duplicate files and spacingACX’s own help page says it does not detect noise floor or editing errors
ACX Check for AudacityLevel, peaks and noise floorNot the MP3 format, room tone or credits, and not how the audio sounds
ACX’s reviewEvery submission rule, including two with no number: consistent sound and no extra soundsACX publishes no threshold for how much processing is too much

ACX answers the question on its own help page. Its analysis tool is automated and cannot detect every error: editing, extraneous noise and dynamics are found afterwards, by its quality assurance team. Every title goes through that review, against all of the submission requirements.

What sends a passing file back

These come from ACX’s own rules and from authors’ threads on the Audacity Forum. ACX publishes no rejection figures, so nobody can tell you which is most common.

  • Noise reduction pushed too far. In a 2019 thread, a file measured below −60 dB and ACX still returned it. Its engineer said noise reduction had made the narration hard to understand.
  • Pauses processed to silence. Another 2019 author’s files read near −90 dB and came back with the note “All files contain buzz”. Forum regulars pointed at the processing: unnatural silence between words. Keep the room’s quiet sound.
  • Passing by a hair. In January 2024, 26 files measured between −60.6 and −74.7 dB and ACX returned them for background noise. The author brought the floor to about −65 dB and the book was accepted.
  • A hum under the voice. In 2020, 15 files passed Audacity’s ACX Check and failed ACX three times for noise. A hum turned up in the recording.
  • A level ACX measures its own way. In 2025 a file that read −22.91 dB RMS in Audacity came back from ACX as 0.1 dB too quiet. ACX says RMS and peak readings differ from one meter to another, and forum regulars add that MP3 encoding shifts levels slightly.
  • An MP3 made from an MP3. Regulars warn against editing or exporting an MP3 a second time. Keep the work in WAV and export the MP3 once, at the end.
  • Chapters that don’t match, or extra sounds. ACX asks for consistent levels, tone and noise across the book, and for files free of pops, clicks, mouth noise and outtakes. No meter reads either one. See chapters that don’t match.

Leave a margin

A file that passes by a tenth of a decibel can fail on ACX’s side. Aim inside the limits, not at them.

RuleACX’s limitAim for
Noise floorbelow −60 dB RMS−63 to −65 dB
Level−23 to −18 dB RMSabout −20 dB
Peaksbelow −3 dB−3.5 dB

Then measure the MP3 you are about to upload, not the project it came from.

Read ACX’s notice first

When ACX finds a problem, it sends a notice saying what needs correcting, by email and to your ACX message center. In Account Settings, under Notifications, switch on Production updates and Change requests so it reaches you.

If the notice is unclear, reply to that email: ACX says it reaches the quality assurance engineer who wrote it. Then fix what it names and resubmit. The title goes back into the review queue, and ACX asks you to contact it if a title sits in review for more than a few days.

Fix it in this order

  1. Go back to the original recording, not the processed MP3.
  2. Take off any noise gate. Leave the room’s quiet sound between sentences.
  3. Clean the noise gently. If your voice turns watery, back off. Steps: noise reduction in Audacity.
  4. Set the level, then limit the peaks, with the margins above.
  5. Export the MP3 once, at 192 kbps constant bit rate.
  6. Check that MP3 with a tool that reports the noise floor.
  7. Listen to the whole chapter once, then upload it unchanged.

If the room echoes, no step here fixes it. Record that chapter again in a closet full of clothes. For noise alone, see noise floor too high.

Fix it in ChapterBooth

Drop the rejected chapter on the free ACX Check. It runs in your browser, nothing is uploaded, and it reports level, peaks, noise floor, room tone and format in one pass.

Press Fix it free and ChapterBooth removes the noise with a speech‑trained cleaner that leaves your voice alone, then sets the level. You hear the first minute in about three minutes, and the first 45 minutes of finished audio cost nothing. When a recording is past saving, the check says so before you spend anything.

Paid hours carry a technical guarantee: if ACX rejects an unchanged export for levels, peaks, noise floor, room tone or format, we re‑master it free, or refund that book. It doesn’t cover performance or narration notes.

What no checker can promise

ACX publishes its numbers, not the point where processing becomes too much. That call is made in review. So no checker, ours included, can promise the part where ACX listens. A checker can keep you inside the numbers with room to spare, and tell you when a recording needs to be made again.

Questions

Does passing Audio Lab mean ACX will accept my book?

No. ACX’s help page says Audio Lab does not detect noise floor or editing errors. Its quality assurance team reviews for those, and for extraneous noise and dynamics, after you submit.

Why was I rejected for noise when my noise floor passed?

A reading close to −60 dB can fail on ACX’s side. Heavy noise reduction and silenced pauses also lower the number while leaving a sound ACX’s reviewers turn back.

Do I have to record the chapter again?

Not for noise or levels, if you kept the original recording and the noise isn’t too loud. Echo and clipping are in the recording itself: record those parts again.

How long does the second review take?

ACX gives no fixed time. Its help page says a resubmitted title goes back into the review queue, and to contact ACX if a title stays in review for more than a few days.

Sources

  • ACX, “ACX audio submission requirements”: acx.com, read 18 November 2026.
  • ACX, “Check your audio quality”: acx.com, read 18 November 2026.
  • ACX, “Quality assurance issues”: acx.com, read 18 November 2026.
  • ACX, “Submit ACX audiobook for quality review”: acx.com, read 18 November 2026.
  • Audacity Forum thread, April 2019: floor below −60 dB, returned for noise reduction: forum.audacityteam.org, read 18 November 2026.
  • Audacity Forum thread, June 2019: a 15-hour book returned for buzz: forum.audacityteam.org, read 18 November 2026.
  • Audacity Forum thread, July 2020: 15 files pass the plugin, fail ACX: forum.audacityteam.org, read 18 November 2026.
  • Audacity Forum thread, January 2024: 26 files near the limit: forum.audacityteam.org, read 18 November 2026.
  • Audacity Forum thread, August 2025: level 0.1 dB short on ACX’s side: forum.audacityteam.org, read 18 November 2026.
  • Audacity Forum thread, March 2026: files pass Audio Lab: forum.audacityteam.org, read 18 November 2026.

Published 18 November 2026 · ACX rules checked on acx.com on 18 November 2026. ACX and Audible are trademarks of Audible, Inc. ChapterBooth is not affiliated with either.

Rejected chapter? Fix this one free.

Check this chapter

45 free minutes. No card.